HOW TO RECOVER DEBT WHEN THERE IS NO WRITTEN LOAN AGREEMENT

- Introduction:
A creditor can recover a debt in Nigeria without a signed agreement if the law permits the transaction to be made informally and the evidence establishes that the defendant owes the amount claimed. A loan agreed by telephone, an order placed through WhatsApp or a service commissioned orally may give rise to an enforceable obligation. The creditor must establish who agreed to pay, what the parties agreed, when payment became due and how much remains outstanding.
The records left by an informal transaction serve different purposes. A bank statement may show that money changed hands. An invoice identifies what the supplier billed. A WhatsApp conversation may explain why the money was transferred or when the buyer agreed to pay. An admission may confirm part or all of the balance. Their value depends on how closely they connect the defendant (alleged debtor) to the obligation claimed.
This article examines how Nigerian courts determine whether an informal transaction created a debt, whether the records are admissible and what they prove once admitted.
2.0. When An Informal Agreement Creates An Enforceable Debt:
2.1. Proving the agreement and its terms.
A contract may be made orally, through an exchange of messages or through a combination of words of mouth and conduct. What the court considers is whether there was an offer, acceptance, consideration, an intention to create legal relations and sufficient certainty about the essential terms. In BFI Group Corporation v Bureau of Public Enterprises (2012) 18 NWLR (Pt 1332) 209, the Supreme Court examined the parties’ communications and dealings in deciding whether they had reached a binding agreement. In Odutola v Papersack Nigeria Ltd (2006) 18 NWLR (Pt 1012) 470, which concerned an alleged oral agreement affecting an existing lease, the Court emphasised the need for credible evidence of who took part, when and where the agreement was made and what the parties said.
In an oral loan claim, the creditor should be able to explain who requested the money, who agreed to repay it, how it was advanced and when repayment fell due. In a claim for goods or services, the corresponding questions concern the order, the agreed price or basis for calculating it, performance and the payment terms. Identifying the debtor sometimes poses serious huddle in a situation where a director made arrangements for a company or where funds went to a third-party account at the borrower’s direction. To succeed in either situation, the creditor must establish who undertook the obligation to pay.
Statutory formalities can affect enforceability. For example, section 13 of the Lagos State Moneylenders Law prescribes a signed written memorandum and related requirements for loans within its scope. Whether those requirements apply depends on the statutory definition of a moneylender and the circumstances of the transaction. Separately, where the parties reduced their terms to a document, section 128 of the Evidence Act 2011 generally requires proof of those terms through the document or admissible secondary evidence of its contents. Subject to its exceptions, the section restricts the use of oral evidence to contradict or vary the recorded terms.
2.2 The burden and standard of proof.
Under sections 131–134 of the Evidence Act, the party asserting the facts on which his claim depends bears the initial burden of proof. A civil debt claim is generally decided on the balance of probabilities. The creditor must first present evidence capable of establishing the obligation and the amount due. If the debtor accepts that the debt arose but asserts that it was repaid, the debtor ordinarily bears the burden of proving repayment. The creditor’s calculation should account for payments that the records already establish.
3. Bank Transfers, Invoices And Records Of Performance:
3.1 Bank transfers.
A bank statement or transfer receipt can establish the date, amount, accounts, reference and recorded narration of a transfer. The same payment, however, may be consistent with a loan, gift, investment, purchase, reimbursement or mistake. A narration such as “loan” carries greater weight when it corresponds with a prior request for a loan or a later promise to repay. If the sender entered the narration alone, it records the sender’s description of the transaction. Evidence of the parties’ dealings helps establish whether the recipient shared that understanding.
The Central Bank of Nigeria’s Regulation on Instant (Inter-Bank) Electronic Funds Transfer Services in Nigeria requires specified details, including the transaction narration, to accompany instant transfer messages. It also requires the beneficiary’s statement to reflect certain details to aid reconciliation. These requirements help identify and trace the transfer. The court determines its legal purpose from the evidence of the transaction as a whole.
Where receipt is disputed, a bank-issued statement or transaction confirmation can help establish whether the transfer was completed, credited or reversed. Where the money went to a third-party account, the creditor should connect the payment to the alleged debtor’s instruction. If the parties had several dealings, the payment reference, timing and contemporaneous messages can help identify the particular loan, invoice or instalment to which the payment relates.
In D. Radda Ventures (Nig) Ltd v Unity Bank Plc (2022), the Court of Appeal explained that a statement of account alone was insufficient to establish liability for a disputed overall debit balance. The claimant had to explain the entries and how it arrived at the balance. Although the case concerned a bank’s claim, the same evidential difficulty arises in informal lending when a creditor relies on several advances, charges and repayments. Each material entry should be accounted for in the sum pleaded.
3.2 Invoices, delivery records and part payments.
An invoice identifies the goods or services billed, the price claimed and, where recorded, the payments credited and balance asserted. Its evidential weight increases when a purchase order, delivery note, proof of collection, signed job card, message approving the work or payment linked to the invoice establishes the buyer’s involvement. A signed delivery note may prove receipt while leaving the agreed price, the quality of the goods or the signatory’s authority in dispute. Likewise, a part payment can corroborate the transaction if the evidence connects it to the invoice or instalment in issue.
Section 51 of the Evidence Act, as amended in 2023, makes relevant entries in books of account or electronic records admissible, but those entries alone are insufficient to charge a person with liability. The provision is directly relevant to claims based on a sales ledger or electronic accounting records. A supplier claiming several unpaid invoices should reconcile them against orders, delivery records, returns, credit notes and receipts. The resulting schedule should allow the court to follow the calculation from the original charges to the amount outstanding.
4. WhatsApp Messages And Electronic Evidence:
4.1 What a WhatsApp conversation can establish.
WhatsApp messages can record negotiations, acceptance, delivery instructions, confirmation of receipt or an undertaking to pay. They may contain the essential terms of a contract or confirm an agreement reached elsewhere. Suppose one party requests ₦2 million and promises to repay it by a specified date, and the other accepts and transfers the corresponding amount. The exchange and the transfer together may establish the terms and performance of the loan. A more tentative response, such as “I will see what I can do”, requires the court to examine whether the words express assent, continue a negotiation or refer to a different obligation.
In Emmanuel Chukwuka Akabuwe v Eric Inameti Bassey, an FCT District Court sitting in its small claims jurisdiction relied on the parties’ WhatsApp conversation and the other evidence before it to find that a loan had been made and that repayment terms had been agreed. The court had a substantial exchange before it, and the defendant ultimately presented no evidence in defence. The decision illustrates how a conversation can supply particulars that would ordinarily appear in a formal loan agreement.
4.2 Admissibility under the Evidence Act.
Screenshots, chat exports, downloaded bank statements and electronic invoices must be considered under the Evidence Act 2011 as amended by the Evidence (Amendment) Act 2023. The amendment expressly brought electronic records within relevant parts of section 84 and inserted sections 84A–84D. Section 84A provides for a statutory writing requirement to be met where the information is made available electronically and remains accessible for subsequent reference. Section 84B addresses the treatment of qualifying electronic outputs as documents. Section 84C addresses authentication by digital signature or a qualifying electronic authentication technique. Where a transaction also requires a signature or another prescribed formality, that requirement calls for separate analysis.
Section 84(2) concerns the regular use of the relevant computer, the ordinary supply of information of the relevant kind, the proper operation of the computer or the effect of any malfunction, and the relationship between the output and the information supplied. A certificate under section 84(4) should identify the record, describe how it was produced, give appropriate particulars of the device involved and address the applicable statutory conditions. It should purport to be signed by a person occupying a responsible position in relation to the operation of the device or the management of the relevant activities.
In Kubor v Dickson (2013) 4 NWLR (Pt 1345) 534, the Supreme Court rejected internet printouts tendered without the requisite evidential foundation. In Impact Solutions Ltd v International Breweries Plc (2018) 16 NWLR (Pt 1645) 377, the Court of Appeal explained that the statutory conditions could be established by suitable oral evidence or by a certificate. Both decisions preceded the 2023 amendment and should be read alongside the amended provisions. Their practical significance is that the party tendering an electronic record should be able to explain how it was produced and why it is reliable.
4.3 Authorship, authority and completeness.
A certificate explaining how a chat was exported addresses the production of the exhibit. The court may still need evidence of who sent the messages and whether that person had authority to act for the defendant. A saved contact name carries limited weight because the device owner can assign or change it. The telephone number, previous dealings through the account, references to facts known to the parties, matching payments and testimony from a participant can help establish authorship.
The full conversation should be preserved, together with relevant attachments and, where available, the original device and exported chat. The messages immediately before and after an alleged admission often determine its meaning. “I will pay on Friday” may appear to confirm a debt until an earlier message shows that the parties were discussing a different invoice or that the promise was conditional. A complete record also allows a witness to explain how the messages were retrieved and how they relate to the transaction.
5. Admissions, Acknowledgements And Limitation:
5.1 The effect of an admission.
Sections 20–26 of the Evidence Act govern the relevance and proof of admissions. An admissible statement by the debtor, or by a person whose statement is attributable to the debtor, can help establish the obligation, a particular balance or a promise to pay on a specified date. Under section 27, an admission can be explained or rebutted, although it may operate as an estoppel in an appropriate case. Section 123 provides that facts formally admitted in pleadings or in another manner contemplated by that section ordinarily need no further proof, subject to the court’s discretion. An open WhatsApp admission and a formal admission in a statement of defence can therefore have different procedural consequences.
The words used determine the scope of the admission. “I owe ₦900,000 on Invoice 17 and will pay by 30 June” identifies a transaction, a balance and a date. “I received the money” confirms receipt and leaves the purpose of the transfer unresolved. “I owe the principal but dispute the interest” narrows the issue to the basis and amount of the additional claim. Any conditions, disputed entries or subsequent credits must also be taken into account. A request for more time or a part payment can corroborate the debt where it is clearly linked to the obligation sued upon.
Settlement communications require particular care. Section 26 excludes an admission made on an express condition that it will be withheld from evidence or in circumstances from which the court can infer that the parties agreed to that condition. An open confirmation of a balance may be admissible, while a proposal made in protected settlement negotiations may be excluded. The circumstances in which the statement was made determine whether the protection applies.
5.2 When an acknowledgement or payment affects limitation.
The use of an acknowledgement as evidence of a debt is distinct from its effect on the time allowed for bringing the claim. In Lagos, section 8(1)(a) of the Limitation Law generally prescribes six years from accrual for an action founded on simple contract. Under sections 30 and 31, a qualifying acknowledgement or payment can cause a right of action for a debt or other liquidated pecuniary claim to be treated as accruing afresh during a current limitation period, subject to the statutory conditions. An acknowledgement for this purpose must be in writing and signed by the person making it. Section 30(7) bars revival of a claim that is already statute-barred by a subsequent acknowledgement or payment.
A WhatsApp message may therefore be useful evidence of an admission even where its effect on limitation is uncertain. A creditor relying on the message to establish fresh accrual must address the statutory writing and signature requirements, the attribution of the message and its timing. For a part payment, the creditor should establish who made it, to whom it was made and which debt it concerned.
6. Preparing And Bringing The Claim:
6.1 Plead the transaction and reconcile the amount.
The creditor should plead how the agreement arose, who made it, its essential terms, what was advanced or supplied, when payment became due and how the balance was calculated. Each material fact should be supported by a witness or record the creditor can properly introduce in evidence. Any claim for pre-judgment interest should state its legal basis, rate and period separately. In Ekwunife v Wayne (West Africa) Ltd (1989) 5 NWLR (Pt 122) 422, the Supreme Court distinguished interest claimed as a substantive entitlement from interest on a judgment debt. An agreement to repay principal, by itself, leaves the claimed interest rate to be independently established.
Consider a supplier claiming ₦1.8 million for goods ordered over the telephone. The supplier has an invoice for ₦2.4 million, a signed delivery note, a bank credit of ₦600,000 and a WhatsApp message in which the buyer confirms receipt and refers to the outstanding ₦1.8 million. The invoice identifies the charge, the delivery note supports performance, the bank record shows the credit and the message links the buyer to the claimed balance. If the buyer says the credit was for an earlier order, the payment narration, transaction dates and the parties’ reconciliation may resolve which account should receive the credit.
6.2 Establish when payment fell due and choose the procedure.
Determine whether the parties fixed a payment date or whether the relevant terms or law made demand a condition of payment or suit. A demand letter can identify the transaction, explain the balance and specify when payment is required. Keep evidence of service and comply with the chosen court’s pre-action requirements. The date a creditor sends a demand and the date the cause of action accrued may differ. Limitation should be calculated by reference to the applicable law and the facts that made the obligation enforceable.
Article 2 of the Lagos Practice Direction on Small Claims 2023 permits an eligible claimant to bring a liquidated money demand of up to ₦5 million, excluding interest and costs, subject to the prescribed territorial and demand requirements. A liquidated demand is a fixed sum or one that can be calculated on an ascertainable basis. In the Lagos High Court, Order 13 of the High Court of Lagos State (Civil Procedure) Rules 2019 allows a claimant who reasonably believes there is no defence to apply for summary judgment with the originating process and prescribed supporting documents.
Where the defendant raises a substantial dispute about the oral terms, the authorship of a message, delivery or repayment, the disputed issues may require a trial. In United Bank for Africa Plc v Jargaba (2007) 11 NWLR (Pt 1045) 247, the Supreme Court considered the significance of a genuine triable issue under the undefended-list procedure. The applicable procedure depends on the rules of the particular court and the nature of the dispute disclosed by the evidence.
7. Conclusion:
A creditor can recover a debt without a signed agreement where an enforceable obligation is established and the evidence proves the identity of the debtor and the amount outstanding. The records must allow the court to determine why money was transferred or goods were supplied, what the defendant undertook to pay and when that obligation fell due.
A transfer can establish that money changed hands. An invoice can identify the amount billed. A WhatsApp exchange can establish the terms or link a payment to a particular transaction. An admission can confirm the balance or narrow the issues for trial. Their combined value depends on accurate attribution, compliance with the rules of evidence and a reconciliation that accounts for every material payment and credit.

Leave a Reply